The ‘what more does he need to do take’ needs to end.
More often than not, it’s a matchup thing, or a game plan thing. It’s very rarely an issue with the player thing.
Learn from the Simmonds/England non-selection, it’s not because he’s crap, it’s because he doesn’t fit the game plan.
Maybe Gats has seen something in which he can exploit with some beef early and then naked pace late.
People are forgetting that SA gave Gats far more information about them because they chose not to play an A team.